| 1919/20 | 1920/21 | 1921/22 | 1922/23 | 1923/24 | 1924/25 | ||||||||
| DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | ||||||||
| 1 | Lowther Utd | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | R | Durham Light Infantry | 1 | Knaresborough | ||||
| 2 | Rowntrees | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | R | Burton Lane C&I | 2 | R | 8th Hussars | |||
| 3 | Acomb | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | R | New Earswick | 3 | Cheshire Regt | ||||
| 4 | Selby | 4 | NO INFO | 4 | NO INFO | 4 | NO INFO | 4 | R | Dringhouses | 4 | Tadcaster Albion | |
| 5 | Knaresborough | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | Thirsk Town | 5 | R | Dringhouses | ||||
| 6 | Heworth PC | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | Malton Town | 6 | Malton Town | |||||
| 7 | Malton Utd | 7 | 7 | 7 | 7 | R | Archbishop Holgates OB | 7 | R | Rowntrees | |||
| 8 | Thirsk | 8 | 8 | 8 | 8 | Ripon City | 8 | RR | Archbishop Holgates OB | ||||
| 9 | St Clements | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | R | Rowntrees | 9 | Ripon City | ||||
| 10 | John Smiths (Tadcaster) | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 | R | Fishergate | 10 | R | Fishergate OB | |||
| 11 | 612 Company RASC | 11 | 11 | 11 | 11 | R | St Clements | 11 | New Earswick | ||||
| 12 | 12 | R | Acomb WMC | 12 | Thirsk Town | ||||||||
| 13 | Malton Utd | 13 | R | Burton Lane C&I | |||||||||
| R = team in Reserve League | 14 | R | St Clements | ||||||||||
| R = team in Reserve League | |||||||||||||
| DIVISION TWO | DIVISION TWO | DIVISION TWO | DIVISION TWO | DIVISION TWO/1 | DIVISION TWO/1 | ||||||||
| 1 | Burton Lane WMC | 1 | Fishergate OB | 1 | Archbishop Holgates OB | 1 | St Lawrences WMC | 1 | R | St Lawrences WMC | 1 | St Lawrences WMC | |
| 2 | Bishopthorpe | 2 | Cawood Utd | 2 | New Earswick | 2 | Selby WMC | 2 | South Bank WMC | 2 | R | Clarence C&I | |
| 3 | Cawood Utd | 3 | Dringhouses | 3 | Easingwold | 3 | Poppleton Utd | 3 | Strensall Utd | 3 | Malton Bible Class | ||
| 4 | Crockey Hill | 4 | Archbishop Holgates OB | 4 | Malton Bible Class | 4 | Bishopthorpe | 4 | Huntington | 4 | Old Malton | ||
| 5 | Easingwold | 5 | St Cuthberts | 5 | Cawood Utd | 5 | RASC | 5 | Norton St Peters | 5 | Norton St Peters | ||
| 6 | Fishergate OB | 6 | Easingwold | 6 | Fishergate OB | 6 | 5th West Yorks | 6 | Malton Bible Class | 6 | R | Huntington | |
| 7 | Melbourne Victoria | 7 | Malton Bible Class | 7 | RASC | 7 | Cawood Utd | 7 | Easingwold | 7 | Strensall Utd | ||
| 8 | South Bank AS | 8 | St Olave's | 8 | 5th West Yorks | 8 | Selby Olympia | 8 | R | Osbaldwick | 8 | Easingwold | |
| 9 | St Cuthberts | 9 | South Bank WMC | 9 | Bishopthorpe | 9 | New Earswick | 9 | R | Model School OB | 9 | Malton Utd | |
| 10 | Wesley Brotherhood | 10 | New Earswick | 10 | Huntington | 10 | Easingwold | 10 | Haxby | 10 | RASC | ||
| 11 | Yeomanry Hussars | 11 | Escrick | 11 | Selby WMC | 11 | Malton Bible Class | 11 | R | Adams Athletic | 11 | Sowerby | |
| 12 | YMCA | 12 | Bishopthorpe | 12 | Catholic Utd | 12 | Huntington PC | ||||||
| 13 | Stamford Bridge | 13 | St Cuthberts | R = team in Reserve League | R = team in Reserve League | ||||||||
| 14 | Model School OB | ||||||||||||
| DIVISION THREE | DIVISION THREE A | DIVISION THREE A | DIVISION THREE A | DIVISION TWO/2 | DIVISION TWO/2 | ||||||||
| 1 | Central Mission | 1 | Huntington | 1 | Poppleton Utd | 1 | Model School OB | 1 | Tadcaster Albion | 1 | Selby Olympia | ||
| 2 | Catholic Utd | 2 | Fulford Utd | 2 | Osbaldwick | 2 | Heslington | 2 | R | 5th West Yorks | 2 | Terry's | |
| 3 | Church Fenton | 3 | Catholic Utd | 3 | Heslington | 3 | Phoenix WMC | 3 | Terry's | 3 | Selby Bank House | ||
| 4 | New Earswick | 4 | RASC | 4 | Skelton Utd | 4 | Boston Spa | 4 | British Legion | 4 | R | British Legion | |
| 5 | Old Priory AS | 5 | Church Fenton | 5 | New Central WMC | 5 | Old Priory AS | 5 | R | Phoenix WMC | 5 | R | 5th West Yorks |
| 6 | Osbaldwick | 6 | Clifton Utd | 6 | Old Priory AS | 6 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 6 | Selby Olympia | 6 | Boston Spa | ||
| 7 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 7 | Heslington | 7 | Stamford Bridge | 7 | Acomb AS | 7 | RASC | 7 | Barlby Bank Utd | ||
| 8 | Raimes Viola | 8 | Riccall | 8 | Fulford Utd | 8 | Osbaldwick | 8 | Selby WMC | 8 | Phoenix WMC | ||
| 9 | Riccall | 9 | Old Priory AS | 9 | St Lawrences WMC | 9 | Fulford Utd | 9 | Tadcaster Trades Hall | 9 | R | Osbaldwick | |
| 10 | St Olave's | 10 | Osbaldwick | 10 | Model School OB | 10 | New Central WMC | 10 | Boston Spa | 10 | R | Model School OB | |
| 11 | Salem Institute | 11 | Raimes Viola | 11 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 11 | Stamford Bridge | 11 | Barkston Ash | ||||
| 12 | Skelton Utd | 12 | Skelton Utd | 12 | Riccall | 12 | Catholic Utd | R = team in Reserve League | R = team in Reserve League | ||||
| 13 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 13 | Copmanthorpe | 13 | Church Fenton | ||||||||
| 14 | Copmanthorpe | 14 | Skelton Utd | ||||||||||
| DIVISION THREE B | DIVISION THREE B | DIVISION THREE B | DIVISION THREE/1 | DIVISION THREE/1 | |||||||||
| 1 | Poppleton Utd | 1 | Phoenix WMC | 1 | Manor School OBs | 1 | R | Clarence C&I | 1 | R | Poppleton Road Old Boys | ||
| 2 | Central WMC | 2 | Terry's | 2 | RGA | 2 | Barlby Bank Utd | 2 | Acomb AS | ||||
| 3 | Sand Hutton | 3 | Church Fenton | 3 | Central Mission | 3 | Selby Bank House | 3 | Sand Hutton | ||||
| 4 | NER Athletic | 4 | NER Athletic | 4 | Terry's | 4 | R | Old Priory AS | 4 | Cooks Employees | |||
| 5 | Crescent WMC | 5 | Haxby WMC | 5 | Haxby WMC | 5 | Fulford Utd | 5 | R | LMS Railway | |||
| 6 | Terry's | 6 | RGA | 6 | Stockton on Forest | 6 | Selby Amateurs | 6 | Heslington | ||||
| 7 | Haxby Road OB | 7 | Sand Hutton | 7 | Gate Helmsley | 7 | RGA | 7 | New Central WMC | ||||
| 8 | Pocklington | 8 | Haxby Road OB | 8 | NER Athletic | 8 | Church Fenton | 8 | Stamford Bridge | ||||
| 9 | Newton on Ouse | 9 | Stockton on Forest | 9 | Copmanthorpe WMCA | 9 | Ulleskelf | 9 | Newton on Ouse | ||||
| 10 | Haxby | 10 | York Records | 10 | Sand Hutton | 10 | Royal Corps of Signals | 10 | Shipton Utd | ||||
| 11 | Phoenix WMC | 11 | Central Mission | 11 | Barlby Bank Utd | 11 | Groves Wesleyans | 11 | Haxby Road OB | ||||
| 12 | Scarcroft OB | 12 | Newton on Ouse | 12 | City 10GT | 12 | Dunnington | ||||||
| 13 | Haxby Road OB | 13 | City WMC | ||||||||||
| Escrick withdrew after 10 games | |||||||||||||
| DIVISION THREE/2 | DIVISION THREE/2 | ||||||||||||
| 1 | LMS Railway | 1 | Fulford Utd | ||||||||||
| 2 | Heslington | 2 | Poppleton Utd | ||||||||||
| 3 | Sand Hutton | 3 | Old Priory AS | ||||||||||
| 4 | Acomb AS | 4 | Barkston Ash | ||||||||||
| 5 | Stamford Bridge | 5 | City WMC | ||||||||||
| 6 | Newton on Ouse | 6 | Groves Wesleyans | ||||||||||
| 7 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 7 | RGA | ||||||||||
| 8 | Gate Helmsley | 8 | Church Fenton | ||||||||||
| 9 | New Central WMC | 9 | Selby Amateurs | ||||||||||
| 10 | Wesley Brotherhood | 10 | Ulleskelf | ||||||||||
| 11 | Shipton Utd | 11 | Appleton Roebuck | ||||||||||