| 1930/31 | 1931/32 | 1932/33 | 1933/34 | 1934/35 | |||||
| DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | DIVISION ONE | |||||
| 1 | Rowntrees | 1 | Selby OCO | 1 | Dringhouses | 1 | Knaresborough | 1 | Knaresborough |
| 2 | Northumberland Fusiliers | 2 | Dringhouses | 2 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 2 | Selby Brayton Road | 2 | Railway Institute |
| 3 | Ripon City | 3 | Clarence C&I | 3 | Knaresborough | 3 | Johns Smiths (Tadcaster) | 3 | Manchester Regt. |
| 4 | Dringhouses | 4 | 2nd West Yorks | 4 | Selby OCO | 4 | Terry's | 4 | Dringhouses |
| 5 | LNER P'way | 5 | Ripon City | 5 | 2nd West Yorks | 5 | Northumberland Fusiliers | 5 | Wetherby JIL |
| 6 | Thirsk | 6 | Rowntrees | 6 | Terry's | 6 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 6 | St Clements |
| 7 | Fishergate OB | 7 | New Earswick | 7 | Rowntrees | 7 | Tadcaster Albion | 7 | Selby OCO |
| 8 | New Earswick | 8 | Royal Artillery | 8 | Clarence C&I | 8 | Selby OCO | 8 | Johns Smiths (Tadcaster) |
| 9 | St Clements | 9 | LNER P'way | 9 | New Earswick | 9 | Dringhouses | 9 | New Earswick |
| 10 | Malton Town | 10 | St Clements | 10 | Northumberland Fusiliers | 10 | Rowntrees | 10 | Tadcaster Albion |
| 11 | Knaresborough (resigned) | 11 | Malton Town | 11 | Royal Artillery | 11 | St Clements | 11 | Selby Brayton Road |
| 12 | St Lawrences WMC (resigned) | 12 | Thirsk (resigned) | 12 | LNER Institute | 12 | New Earswick | 12 | Terry's |
| 13 | St Clements | 13 | Royal Artillery (resigned) | ||||||
| Malton Town (resigned) | |||||||||
| DIVISION TWO Group 1 | DIVISION TWO Group 1 | DIVISION TWO | DIVISION TWO Group 1 | DIVISION TWO Group 1 | |||||
| 1 | Clarence C&I | 1 | Selby Brayton Road | 1 | Johns Smiths (Tadcaster) | 1 | LNER Institute | 1 | Easingwold Town |
| 2 | Fulford Utd | 2 | Terry's | 2 | Malton Bible Class | 2 | Taylors (Norton) Utd | 2 | Malton Bible Class |
| 3 | Selby Brayton Road | 3 | Fulford Utd | 3 | Easingwold Town | 3 | Duncombe Park | 3 | Duncombe Park |
| 4 | Johns Smiths (Tadcaster) | 4 | Johns Smiths (Tadcaster) | 4 | Selby Brayton Road | 4 | Old Malton St Mary's | 4 | Old Malton St Mary's |
| 5 | Terry's | 5 | Tadcaster Albion | 5 | Tadcaster Albion | 5 | Old Priory | 5 | Taylors (Norton) Utd |
| 6 | Selby East Common | 6 | Fishergate OB | 6 | Fulford Utd | 6 | Fulford Utd | 6 | Stillington |
| 7 | LNER Institute | 7 | Old Priory | 7 | Stillington | 7 | Stillington | 7 | Easingwold Rangers |
| 8 | Old Priory | 8 | RAMC | 8 | Huntington Rovers | 8 | Easingwold Town | 8 | Swinton Utd |
| 9 | Bishopthorpe | 9 | LNER Institute | 9 | Malton Utd | 9 | Fishergate OB | 9 | Malton Utd |
| 10 | Church Fenton | 10 | Tang Hall WMC | 10 | Malton Bible Class | ||||
| 11 | RASC | 11 | Easingwold Rangers | ||||||
| DIVISION TWO Group 2 | DIVISION TWO Group 2 | 12 | Easingwold Rangers | 12 | Malton Utd | ||||
| 1 | RA & Signals | 1 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 13 | Old Priory | ||||
| 2 | 5th Fusiliers | 2 | Easingwold Town | 14 | South Bank | DIVISION TWO Group 2 | DIVISION TWO Group 2 | ||
| 3 | Easingwold | 3 | South Bank | 15 | Fishergate OB | 1 | 3rd Hussars | 1 | Riccall Utd |
| 4 | Malton Bible Class | 4 | Poppleton Road WMC | 16 | Poppleton Road WMC (Resigned) | 2 | Riccall Utd | 2 | Leeman Road Utd |
| 5 | Easingwold Rangers | 5 | Tang Hall WMC | 3 | Poppleton Utd | 3 | Huntington Rovers | ||
| 6 | 5th West Yorks | 6 | Easingwold Rangers | 4 | RASC | 4 | Old Priory | ||
| 7 | South Bank | 7 | Malton Utd | 5 | Pocklington Town | 5 | Market Weighton | ||
| 8 | Malton Utd | 8 | Stillington | 6 | South Bank | 6 | Stamford Bridge | ||
| 9 | Poppleton Road Old Boys | 9 | Huntington Rovers | 7 | Stamford Bridge | 7 | Poppleton Utd | ||
| 10 | Stillington | 10 | Malton Bible Class | 8 | Bishopthorpe | 8 | RAMC | ||
| 11 | RASC | 11 | RASC | 9 | Wistow Utd | 9 | RASC | ||
| 10 | Huntington Rovers | 10 | South Bank | ||||||
| 11 | RAMC | 11 | Heslington | ||||||
| DIVISION THREE Group 1 | DIVISION THREE Group 1 | DIVISION THREE Group 1 | DIVISION THREE Group 1 | DIVISION THREE Group 1 | |||||
| 1 | Huntington Rovers | 1 | Acomb Carr Lane | 1 | Stamford Bridge | 1 | Heslington | 1 | Crescent WMC |
| 2 | York Gas | 2 | RAOC | 2 | Pocklington | 2 | Haxby Fellowship | 2 | Haxby Fellowship |
| 3 | Dunnington | 3 | Stamford Bridge | 3 | Heslington | 3 | Crescent WMC | 3 | Clifton CI |
| 4 | Peckett Street UM | 4 | Welburn | 4 | Haxby Fellowship | 4 | Strensall St Mary's | 4 | Sand Hutton |
| 5 | Heslington | 5 | Strensall St Mary's | 5 | Peckett Street UM | 5 | Sand Hutton | 5 | Skelton Utd |
| 6 | Acomb Carr Lane | 6 | Heslington | 6 | Welburn | 6 | Clifton CI | 6 | Welburn |
| 7 | RAOC | 7 | Peckett Street UM | 7 | Strensall St Mary's | 7 | Peckett Street Utd | 7 | Strensall St Mary's |
| 8 | Strensall | 8 | York Gas | 8 | Crescent WMC | 8 | Welburn | 8 | Cookes Employees |
| 9 | Haxby Fellowship | 9 | Dunnington | 9 | Acomb Carr Lane | 9 | Dunnington | 9 | Barton's Athletic |
| 10 | Sessions | 10 | Acomb Wesleyans | 10 | York Gas | 10 | York Gas | 10 | Sheriff Hutton |
| 11 | Stamford Bridge | 11 | Haxby Fellowship | 11 | Sheriff Hutton | 11 | Sheriff Hutton | 11 | Dunnington |
| 12 | Welburn | 12 | Dunnington | 12 | Birch & Sons (Resigned) | 12 | Royal Artillery | ||
| DIVISION THREE Group 2 | DIVISION THREE Group 2 | DIVISION THREE Group 2 | DIVISION THREE Group 2 | DIVISION THREE Group 2 | |||||
| 1 | Poppleton Road WMC | 1 | Riccall Utd | 1 | St Maurices | 1 | Eborcraft | 1 | RAOC |
| 2 | Tadcaster Albion | 2 | St Maurices | 2 | Bishopthorpe | 2 | RAOC | 2 | Escrick St Helens |
| 3 | Riccall Utd | 3 | Barlby & Osgodby | 3 | Riccall Utd | 3 | Skelton Utd | 3 | Lingcroft |
| 4 | St Maurices | 4 | Nunthorpe OB | 4 | Wistow Utd | 4 | Blue Corinthians | 4 | Haxby Road OB |
| 5 | Rechabites | 5 | St Chads | 5 | Nunthorpe OB | 5 | Escrick St Helens | 5 | Blue Corinthians |
| 6 | Poppleton Utd | 6 | Rechabites | 6 | Barlby & Osgodby | 6 | Lingcroft | 6 | Kelfield Utd |
| 7 | Monkgate PM | 7 | Poppleton Utd | 7 | RAMC | 7 | Copmanthorpe | 7 | St Chads |
| 8 | St Chads | 8 | Copmanthorpe | 8 | Lingcroft | 8 | Nunthorpe OB | 8 | Copmanthorpe |
| 9 | Ampersands | 9 | Lingcroft | 9 | Skelton Utd | 9 | St Chads | 9 | Eborcraft |
| 10 | Acomb Wesleyans | 10 | Baptists | 10 | RAOC | 10 | YUWA | 10 | YUWA |
| 11 | Lingcroft | 11 | Church Fenton | 11 | Copmanthorpe | 11 | Church Fenton | 11 | Church Fenton |
| 12 | Baptists | 12 | Ampersands | 12 | Church Fenton | 12 | York Labour | ||
| 13 | York Labour | ||||||||
| 14 | Catholic Utd |